153

Kate Harris 1878–1949

Art Nouveau scent bottle with ivy pattern

R.H. Halford & Sons
London, United Kingdom, 1900
silver, glass
5½ h × 3 dia in (14 × 8 cm)
estimate: $500–700
result: $2,560

Bottle features a Powell glass body with silver mount having sinuous foliate motifs, and the cap having a young woman's profile. Impressed maker's mark and English hallmarks to cap edge and underside. Impressed number to lower edge '352242'. 12.271 ozt. (gross weight).
provenance: Collection of Joel and Carole Bernstein

This work will ship from Lambertville, New Jersey.

print

Jewels in the Crown

by Glenn Adamson

When silver went out of style in Britain, it went fast. Its fall from fashionability began in the 1920s, with the decline of domestic servant culture—all that hollowware does not polish itself—and an ensuing shift toward more informal dining. Those who did still want to buy a silver service had plenty of secondhand options to choose from. By the 1960s, the great workshops of London, Birmingham, and Sheffield had become shadows of their former selves; few have survived to the present day. It is a sad story, but one that makes the silverwork of the immediately preceding Arts & Crafts Movement, seen in its full glory in the collection of Joel and Carole Bernstein, all the more significant. Exquisite on their own terms, these objects also mark the culmination of a centuries-old craft. They are jewels in the crown of silver's long and brilliant history.

Few at the turn of the century would have had any sense of an ending. Silver was then at its absolute height of popularity; long available only to the social elite, it had become a much more widespread expression of refinement. Newly discovered deposits, most famously the Comstock Lode in Nevada, made the metal much more plentiful, and therefore affordable to makers and consumers alike. Modern technology—spinning lathes, rolling mills, die-stamping, and electroplating—further lowered cost while opening up creative possibilities. For manufacturers of silver, it was a golden age.

Arts & Crafts silversmithing has a fascinating place in this story. On the one hand, it defined itself against the sudden profusion of industry. William Morris had influentially contrasted what he called "trade finish," which he viewed as dead and dully predictable, with "that skill of hand, and niceness of observation, without which only a makeshift of art can be got."1 Charles Robert Ashbee, an early adherent of Morris' political and aesthetic theories and the Arts & Crafts Movement's first great exponent of silversmithing, wrote of his own efforts to restore the discipline to its formerly exalted place among the crafts, and "drag it once again out of the industrial mire." For him, this was a matter of social reform even more than a question of aesthetics. His objection to spinning, for example—quickly shaping objects on a lathe, rather than raising them skillfully with a planishing hammer—was that it "destroys the organization of the Silversmith's Shop, and as such it destroys the Craft."2

On the other hand, Arts & Crafts metalsmithing was in many ways symbiotic with "the trade." As Ashbee's own production in the medium matured from its early experimental stage to a serious business proposition, about half of his workforce came from the industrial workshops that he had so vociferously criticized.3 (Just as with Staffordshire ceramics and London furniture, it turned out that "trade finish" actually required a highly skilled workforce.) Furthermore, some of the best Arts & Crafts silver was made by expressly commercial concerns, which took a pragmatic view of process. In Liberty & Co.'s Cymric line—introduced in 1899 at the behest of an innovative Welshman named John Llewellyn, and realized by the Scottish designer Archibald Knox—Celtic knotwork and bright enamel decoration are integrated with austere, proto-modernist silhouettes. The line was further enlivened by the contributions of the Birmingham silversmith Bernard Cuzner and Jessie M. King, one of the celebrated "Glasgow Girls," best known for her children's book illustrations.

As previous scholars have noted, Knox "designed for ease of making," with forms generally die-stamped flat rather than raised from sheet. A faux texture of "hammer marks" was sometimes introduced through molding.4 In 1903, Liberty inaugurated a related line of cast pewter, still more accessible to the middle-class consumer, called Tudric. The allusion was of course to the Tudor era, for some decades the object of Revivalist fascination. At a time when taste in silver tended to gravitate to a generic neo-Georgian, Knox and the other Liberty designers were adapting past precedent in fresh and unexpected ways.

The same can be said for all of the best British Arts & Crafts silver. Ashbee brought all of his creative flair and antiquarian erudition to Renaissance-style tazzas, church chalices, and monumental salt cellars. Harold Landon's casket, in the present sale, translates into metalwork the fine polychromy and overall structure of Jacobean embroidered pieces, while Omar Ramsden's tall potpourri vase has a distinctive pattern, reminiscent of seventeenth-century German metalwork.

Alexander Fisher, who took the leading role in reintroducing pictorial enamel to silversmithing, was especially rigorous in his study of precedents. "This has been a very hard task," he wrote of his technical achievements, "having very little but old books to help me."5 In fact, he also learned a great deal from contemporary French enamel, just one example of the ways that British silversmiths of this era, despite their self-conscious performance of national identity, borrowed from across the channel.

The more widespread variant of that influence came from Art Nouveau, whose attenuated forms, metaphorical rather than materialist in nature, might have seemed an unpromising source for Arts & Crafts makers. This was in fact largely true in other crafts, but silver was very much an exception, as designers like Kate Harris brokered a happy marriage between British and French idioms. Her low-slung but commanding centerpiece from the Bernstein collection, manufactured by William Hutton & Sons, is enlivened by lyrical figuration, handles with "whiplash" lines, and oculi that reveal the green glass within.

It is always a difficult matter to locate the end of the British Arts & Crafts Movement. It never regained its original vitality after the disruption of World War I, to be sure, but its international influence was only getting going, and some of its leading lights continued for years afterward. This was the case, for example, with Omar Ramsden, whose mahogany-lined casket completed in 1925, is one of the undoubted highlights of the Bernstein collection. Ramsden embodied the movement perfectly in his adaptable approach to its ideals. He had proclaimed in 1909 that "the true silversmith of to-day, as in the best Gothic times, is a beater of metals," asserting the primacy of "[production] at first hand by hammer work, without the intermediate processes of modelling, moulding, and casting."6 But as Tanya Harrod has noted, he eventually implemented division of labor in his shop—he originated the ideas, but relied on specialist draftsman, modeler, and chaser. Shapes were often spun rather than raised, and casting was contracted out. As Harrod puts it, "turnover was speedy, enabling medieval forms to be given a topical twist."7

All this may be, but the Bernstein casket is nonetheless a wonder, with surging, almost molten passages evoking Baroque auricular style juxtaposed with heavily defined ornaments more akin to the Neoclassicism of the eighteenth-century master Paul De Lamerie. Like the many other marvels in the Bernstein collection, the object invites us to approach the Arts & Crafts Movement with a newly open mind. There is boundless craftsmanship to be enjoyed here, but it is never doctrinaire; the objects transcend any expectation of earnest historicism through their creators' sheer imagination and design intelligence.

Ensuing generations of silversmiths—whether exponents of Art Deco, Modernism, and even Conceptual Art—would reinvent their vocation time and again. Never more, however, would they really be motivated to challenge mainstream silversmithing, for that once prodigious current was running increasingly dry. In British Arts & Crafts silver, uniquely, we find not only a triumphant recapitulation of the discipline's glorious past, but also a spirit of avant-garde challenge. Silversmithing, at that time and place, was something worth fighting for.


References

1 William Morris, Preface, Arts and Crafts Essays (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1893), pg. xiii
2 C.R. Ashbee, Modern English Silverwork: An Essay (London : B.T. Batsford, 1909), pgs. 4 and 7
3 Alan Crawford, C.R. Ashbee: Architect, Designer, and Romantic Socialist (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1995), pg. 324
4 Victor Arwas, "Archibald Knox: Silver and Jewelry," in Archibald Knox (London: Academy Editions, 1995), pg. 48
5 Quoted in Stephen Pudney, "Alexander Fisher: Pioneer of Arts & Crafts," The Journal of the Decorative Arts Society 1850 – the Present 23 (1999), 70–85: pg. 72
6 Omar Ramsden, "Silversmiths' and Goldsmiths' Work," Journal of the Royal Society of Arts 58 (Jan. 28, 1910), pg. 263
7 Tanya Harrod, The Crafts In Britain in the Twentieth Century (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999), pg. 74